A Case-Control Study Of Asbestos In Drinking Water And Cancer Risk - (1984)

The Potential Cancer Risks of Asbestos in Drinking Water: A Comprehensive Overview

Abstract The study titled "A Case-Control Study of Asbestos in Drinking Water and Cancer Risk" by Lincoln Polissar, Richard K. Severson, and Edwin S. Boatman, published in the American Journal of Epidemiology in 1984, investigates the potential cancer risks associated with asbestos exposure through drinking water. Conducted in Everett, Washington, an area with high concentrations of chrysotile asbestos in its water supply, the study examined 382 cancer cases and 462 controls. Researchers assessed asbestos exposure through interviews, focusing on residence, workplace history, and water consumption. Despite the high asbestos levels in the water, the study found no statistically significant link between asbestos exposure through drinking water and an increased risk of cancer. However, the authors acknowledged the challenges of detecting low-level risks and the limitations of their sample size.

Legal Relevance This study holds significant implications for asbestos-related legal claims, particularly in cases involving environmental exposure. Here’s how it can be applied:

1. Evidence Pathways: The study highlights the presence of asbestos in drinking water, which can be used to establish exposure pathways in legal cases. While the study did not find a statistically significant link, it acknowledges the potential for low-level risks, which could support claims of prolonged or high-level exposure.

2. Occupational History Relevance: The study’s methodology of assessing exposure through residence and workplace history underscores the importance of documenting occupational and environmental exposure. This can be critical in legal cases where plaintiffs need to demonstrate a history of asbestos exposure.

3. Counterarguments to Defense Claims: While the defense may use the study to argue that asbestos in drinking water does not significantly increase cancer risk, plaintiffs can counter by emphasizing the study’s limitations, such as its inability to detect risks for rare cancers or low-level exposures. The study’s acknowledgment of these limitations can be leveraged to argue that it does not definitively rule out a connection.

In summary, this study provides a nuanced perspective that can be utilized by both plaintiffs and defendants in asbestos-related legal cases, depending on the specifics of the exposure and the claims being made.

Occupation Groups at Risk While the study primarily focuses on environmental exposure to asbestos through drinking water, certain occupational groups may still be indirectly affected due to their work environments or involvement in industries where asbestos contamination in water could occur. These groups include:

1. Asbestos Abatement Workers: These professionals are directly involved in handling asbestos and may have knowledge of contamination in water supplies.
2. Utility and Water Treatment Plant Operators: Workers in water treatment facilities may be exposed to asbestos-contaminated water or infrastructure.
3. Construction and Demolition Workers: These workers may encounter asbestos-containing materials that could leach into water supplies during construction or demolition activities.
4. Plumbers and Pipefitters: Asbestos was historically used in water pipes, and these workers may be exposed during repairs or replacements.
5. Industrial Workers: Employees in industries that use asbestos-containing materials may face indirect exposure through contaminated water sources.

These occupations are at higher risk due to their proximity to asbestos-containing materials or infrastructure, making them relevant in legal cases involving asbestos exposure.

Current Medical Understanding The study aligns with current medical knowledge, which suggests that the risk of cancer from ingested asbestos is significantly lower than from inhaled asbestos. However, it also highlights the challenges of detecting low-level risks and the limitations of existing epidemiological methods. While the study concludes that the risk of cancer from asbestos in drinking water is likely very small, it does not definitively rule out the possibility, particularly for rare cancers or prolonged exposure. This aligns with contemporary understanding, which continues to emphasize the need for further research into the health effects of ingested asbestos.

Citation Polissar, L., Severson, R. K., & Boatman, E. S. (1984). A case-control study of asbestos in drinking water and cancer risk. American Journal of Epidemiology, 119(3), 456-471. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a113763

National Library of Medicine Link For additional context and credibility, you can access the study on the National Library of Medicine’s website: Cancer Risk from Asbestos in Drinking Water.

Contact Us Today If you or a loved one has been diagnosed with mesothelioma, lung cancer, stomach cancer, throat cancer, colon cancer, asbestosis, or pleural plaques, you may be entitled to compensation. Our experienced legal team specializes in asbestos-related cases and can help you navigate the complexities of your claim. Contact us today for a free consultation and let us fight for the justice and compensation you deserve. Don’t wait—time is critical in asbestos-related cases. Call us now or fill out our online form to get started.