Cancer Risk From Asbestos In Drinking Water: Summary Of A Case-Control Study In Western Washington - (1983)

The Legal Implications of Asbestos in Drinking Water: A Comprehensive Analysis of a Case-Control Study

Abstract The study titled "Cancer Risk From Asbestos In Drinking Water: Summary Of A Case-Control Study In Western Washington" by Lincoln Polissar, Richard K. Severson, and Edwin S. Boatman, published in Environmental Health Perspectives (1983), explores the potential cancer risks associated with asbestos in drinking water. The research focused on Everett, Washington, where the Sultan River's drinking water contained high concentrations of chrysotile asbestos (200 x 10^6 fibers/liter). The study involved interviews with 382 cancer patients and 462 control individuals to assess exposure levels and cancer risk. The findings revealed no significant difference in asbestos exposure between the cancer cases and the control group, suggesting no conclusive evidence of increased cancer risk from ingested asbestos.

Legal Relevance This study holds significant legal relevance for asbestos-related claims, particularly in cases involving exposure through non-traditional pathways like drinking water. Key points include:

1. Evidence Pathways: The study highlights the importance of detailed exposure assessments, including residence and workplace history, which are critical in establishing causation in asbestos-related legal cases. While the study did not find a strong link between ingested asbestos and cancer, it underscores the necessity of thorough investigations into all potential exposure routes.

2. Occupational History Relevance: The study's methodology, which included interviews with cancer patients and their next-of-kin, demonstrates the value of collecting comprehensive occupational and residential histories. This approach can be applied in legal cases to strengthen claims by identifying prolonged exposure to asbestos-contaminated environments.

3. Counterarguments to Defense Claims: Defense teams often argue that ingested asbestos poses minimal health risks. This study, while not finding a significant cancer risk, does not entirely rule out the potential for harm, particularly in cases of prolonged exposure. Legal teams can use this study to argue for the need for further research and to highlight the uncertainties surrounding ingested asbestos risks.

Occupation Groups at Risk While this study focused on asbestos in drinking water, it indirectly sheds light on occupational groups that may be at higher risk due to exposure to asbestos-contaminated environments. These groups include:

1. Water Utility Workers: Workers involved in maintaining or repairing water systems in areas with asbestos-contaminated water may face prolonged exposure to asbestos fibers.
2. Construction Workers: Those working on infrastructure projects in regions with asbestos-contaminated water supplies may encounter asbestos through both inhalation and ingestion.
3. Industrial Workers: Employees in industries that use water from contaminated sources may be exposed to asbestos fibers during manufacturing processes.
4. Residents in High-Risk Areas: While not an occupation, individuals living in areas with asbestos-contaminated water for decades, as highlighted in the study, may also face increased risks.

These groups are at risk due to their prolonged exposure to asbestos fibers, whether through inhalation or ingestion, making them potential claimants in asbestos-related legal cases.

Current Medical Understanding The study aligns with current medical knowledge, which suggests that the risk of developing cancer from ingested asbestos is significantly lower than from inhaled asbestos. While the study found no significant difference in exposure levels between cancer cases and controls, it highlights the need for further research into the health effects of ingested asbestos. Current medical consensus continues to emphasize the carcinogenic risks of inhaled asbestos, particularly in occupational settings, while acknowledging the limited evidence for ingested asbestos.

Citation Polissar, L., Severson, R. K., & Boatman, E. S. (1983). Cancer risk from asbestos in drinking water: Summary of a case-control study in western Washington. Environmental Health Perspectives, 53, 57-60. https://doi.org/10.1289/ehp.835357

National Library of Medicine Link For additional context and credibility, you can access the study on the National Library of Medicine's website: Cancer Risk From Asbestos In Drinking Water.

Contact Us Today If you or a loved one has been diagnosed with mesothelioma, lung cancer, stomach cancer, throat cancer, colon cancer, asbestosis, or pleural plaques, you may be entitled to compensation. Our experienced legal team specializes in asbestos-related claims and can help you navigate the complexities of your case. Contact us today for a free consultation and let us fight for the justice and compensation you deserve. Call now or fill out our online form to get started.